Critical Evaluation of Ustuwānah al-Mushaf Narratives

Critical Evaluation of Ustuwānah al-Mushaf Narratives


Hadīth

I Introduction

Certain narratives report that the Prophet (sws) would seek out a particular pillar in his mosque where he would offer optional prayers. The pillar was called ust@uwānah al-mus@h@af(the pillar of the mus@h@af) signifying the fact that a mus@h@afof the Qur'ān was placed near it. Opinions differ as to which mus@h@afof the Qur'ān does this refer to?

In this article, an attempt shall be made to ascertain this.

II Representative Text

حدثنا المكي بن إبراهيم قال حدثنا يزيد بن أبي عبيد قال كنت آتي مع سلمة بن الأكوع فيصلي عند الأسطوانة التي عند المصحف فقلت يا أبا مسلم أراك تتحرى الصلاة عند هذه الأسطوانة قال فإني رأيت النبييتحرى الصلاة عندها

Yazīd ibn Abī 'Ubayd says: "I came over with Salamah ibn al-Akwa' [to the Masjid-i Nabawī] and he prayed near the pillar near which the mus@h@afof the Qur'ān was placed. I asked: 'O Abū Muslim, I see you seeking to pray near this pillar.' He replied: 'I saw the Prophet seeking to pray near it.'"[1]

III. Existing Interpretations

In the opinion of al-'Ayni (d. 855 AH), al-Qast@alānī (d. 923 AH) and al-Kashmīrī (d. 1352 AH) the mus@h@afreferred to is one that was found in the times of 'Uthmān (rta) in the masjid al-nabawī and which existed at the time when Yazīd ibn 'Ubayd (d. 146 AH) visited the mosque with Salamah ibn al-Akwa', as referred to by the narrative.[2]

'Imādī (d. 1392 AH),[3] on the other hand, is of the opinion that it refers to the Qur'ānic leaves (s@uh@uf) collected in the times of the Prophet Muh@ammad (sws) and placed in a box[4] in the Prophet's mosque soon after the Prophet's migration to Madīnah. This box was placed near a pillar of the mosque which came to be known by the name ust@uwānah al-mus@h@af(the mus@h@af'spillar). He contends that once the Makkan sūrahs had been copied by the Ans@ār, these s@uh@ufwere taken away from their place in the mosque because the purpose of placing them there was fulfilled as then both the Muhājirīn and the Ans@ār were at par with one another as far as writing the Qur'ān was concerned. They were safely lodged with H@afs@ah (rta) because she was the most literate wife of the Prophet (sws). Whenever some portion of the Qur'ān was revealed, these s@uh@ufwould be brought over from Hafs@ah@'s abode and the new verses would be recorded in them. Both the Muhājirīn and the Ans@ār would also update their own copies of the Qur'ān after that. It was at the place where the s@uh@ufbox was placed and from where withdrawn that the Prophet (sws) would endeavour to offer the prayer regarding it to be a blessed place.

After Hafs@ah@'s death, Marwān ibn H@akam obtained the s@uh@ufand had them destroyed because they had served their purpose as thousands of copies of the s@uh@ufhad been prepared. He also feared that keeping them intact might give the Hypocrites an opportunity to tamper with them.

'Imādī also criticizes the scholars who think that the mush@afreferred to is the mush@afof 'Uthmān (rta) because he thinks that they have merely conjectured in this matter that since 'Uthmān (rta) sent copies to various territories, he must have kept one at the Prophet's mosque.

In order to substantiate his conclusion, 'Imādī's basic premise is that while the narrative of the collection in the time of Abū Bakr is false (and so is the one which depicts a collection in the time of 'Uthmān (rta)), the existence of s@uh@ufwith H@afs@ah (rta) is an established historical fact. This narrative was concocted to undermine the status of s@uh@uf(called "al-imām or al-umm") that were kept in the custody of H@afs@ah (rta) which were actually the same s@uh@ufwhich had been collected in the time of the Prophet (sws).

He presents the following arguments to substantiate his afore-mentioned view.

1. Only the s@uh@ufof the Prophet (sws) could be called "al-imām" or "umm". That Hafs@ah's s@uh@ufwere called umm is evident from a narrative found in the Fad@ā'il al-Qur'ānof Muh@ammad ibn 'Uthmān ibn Abī Shaybah:

حدثنى ابي عن مطلب بن زياد عن السدى عن انس بن مالك قال كان الصحف التى جمعها ابوبكر تسمى اما. فهي كانت عنده الى ان توفاه الله ثم عند عمر حتى توفاه الله ثم عند حفصة زوج النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم. فلما اختلف الناس في القرآن علي عهد عثمان حتى اقتتل الغلمان والمعلمون ، فبلغ ذلك عثمان ، فقال هؤلاء عندنا يلحنون في كتاب الله فمن ناى عنا يكون اكثر لحنا ويكذب بعضهم بعضا. فيا اصحاب رسول الله اجتمعوا فاكتبوا لكل مصراما ماً يقتدون به ويصححون به مصاحمهم ، ثم ارسل الي حفصة ان ارسلى الينا الام ننسحها فى المصاحف ثم نردها اليك واخبرها بما دعاء الى ذلك فاستحسنت وارسلت اليه الام فاستنسخ خمسة مصاحف ثم ارسل الى كل افق مصحفاً وسماه اماماً لذلك الافق وامسك منها مصحفاً عنده ليكون اماما لا هل المدينة

Anas ibn Mālik reported: "The s@uh@uf collected by Abū Bakr were called umm. They remained with him until his death and then with 'Umar until his death; after this, they came in the custody of H@afs@@ah, the Prophet's wife. When people started to differ about the Qur'ān in the times of 'Uthmān – so much so that boys and teachers of the Qur'ān began to quarrel with one another – this news reached 'Uthmān. So he remarked: 'These people are making mistakes while reading the Qur'ān before us; so those who are far away from us would be making more mistakes and would also be rejecting one another. So O Companions of the Prophet! Gather together and write an imām (primary mus@h@af) for each city which people would follow and through it correct their own mas@āh@if.' He then sent a message to H@afs@ah to send to him the umm saying: 'we will copy this into mas@āh@ifand return it to you.' He informed her of the reasons which induced him to undertake this task; she expressed her liking for this undertaking and sent him the umm. 'Uthmān made five copies of this and sent to each part of his territory one copy and named it the imām of that territory and kept one copy for himself so that it could become the imām of the people of Madīnah."[5]

2. If the narratives of collection under Abū Bakr (rta) and 'Uthmān (rta) are fabrications, then the only logical explanation for Hafs@ah's s@uh@ufis that they were the s@uh@ufcollected and compiled by the Prophet (sws).

3. If someone asks: Though the existence of Hafs@ah's s@uh@uf is an established fact, they could still be her personal collection; so why should they be attributed to the Prophet (sws)? The answer to this question is that in the fabricated narrative of collection under 'Uthmān (rta), it is mentioned that 'Uthmān (rta) called for the s@uh@ufwhich were in the custody of H@afs@ah (rta). This could only be because H@afs@ah (rta) had the original s@uh@ufcollected in the Prophet's times because each wife of the Prophet (sws) had s@uh@ufof her own and it was only H@afs@ah's s@uh@ufthat were obtained by 'Uthmān (rta). Leaving aside the other s@uh@ufwhich were in the custody of other wives and just concentrating on the s@uh@ufof H@afs@ah (rta) clearly shows that they had the special status of being the s@uh@uf which the Prophet (sws) had had collected in his time.

4. The fact that the s@uh@uf had been withdrawn from the mosque at one time in the lifetime of the Prophet (sws) is evident from the following narrative:

حدثنا عبد الله حدثني أبي ثنا حماد بن مسعدة عن يزيد عن سلمة انه كان يتحرى موضع المصحف وذكر ان رسول اللهيتحرى ذلك المكان وكان بين المنبر والقبلة ممر شاة

Yazīd [ibn Abī 'Ubayd] narrates from Salamah [ibn al-Akwa'] that he [Salamah] would try to locate the place where the mus@h@afhad been placed, and mentioned that the Prophet (sws) too would try to locate that place; and it was between the pulpit and the qiblah being as big as a place through which a goat could pass.[6]

The words "the Prophet (sws) too would try to locate that place" themselves show that the box in which these s@uh@uf were kept was no longer placed in the mosque since it was only then possible for the Prophet (sws) to search for the spot at which the box was placed and then pray over it.[7]

While providing details about the pillar near which the s@uh@ufbox was placed, he refers to Ibn H@ajar:

قوله التي عند المصحف هذا دال على أنه كان للمصحف موضع خاص به ووقع عند مسلم بلفظ يصلي وراء الصندوق وكأنه كان للمصحف صندوق يوضع فيه والاسطوانة المذكورة حقق لنا بعض مشايخنا أنها المتوسطة في الروضة المكرمة وأنها تعرف باسطوانة المهاجرين قال وروى عن عائشة أنها كانت تقول لو عرفها الناس لاضطربوا عليها بالسهام وإنها أسرتها إلى بن الزبير فكان يكثر الصلاة عندها

The words "[the pillar] near the mus@h@af" of the narrative show that there was a specific place at which the mus@h@afwas placed and in the S@ah@īh@of Muslim[8] the words are "he prayed behind the box" implying that the mus@h@afwas placed in the box. Some of our teachers have corroborated this opinion for us that the pillar referred to was the middle one in the Prophet's tomb. And that it was known as the pillar of the muhājirūn. It is narrated from 'Ā'ishah that had people been aware of it they would have cast lots to come near it and that she had just secretly told Ibn Zubayr about it. He would pray near it a lot.[9]

'Imādī is of the opinion that the words الأسطوانة التي عند المصحف(the pillar near the mus@h@af) found in al-Jāmi' al-s@ah@īh@of Imām Bukhārī[10]can be a cause of confusion (as has been the case with Badr al-Dīn 'Aynī, a famous commentator of al-Bukhārī's al-Jāmi' al-s@ah@īh@)that these s@uh@uf were the ones which constituted one of the copies of the Qur'ān prepared by 'Uthmān (rta) in his time which he placed in the Prophet's mosque and which continued to be there till Yazīd ibn Abī 'Ubayd saw them when he came to pray there with Salamah ibn al-Akwa'. 'Imādī says that actually the words الأسطوانة التي عند المصحف(the pillar near the mus@h@af) mean الأسطوانة التي عند موضع المصحف(the pillar near place of the mus@h@af). This is evident from the words موضع المصحفquoted in Musnad Ah@mad[11](and which also occur in Muslim's al-Jāmi' al-s@ah@īh@[12]).

'Imādī also says that in one of the versions of 'Aynī's commentary on al-Bukhārī, the words are:

قوله ( التي عند المصحف) هذا يدل على أنه كان في مسجد رسول الله موضع خاص للمصحف الذي كان في عهد عثمان

The expression: [the pillar] near the mus@h@af] signifies that in the mosque of the messenger of God, there was a special place for the mus@h@afin the times of 'Uthmān.[13]

'Imādī states that if 'Aynī's statements are interpreted to mean that the box containing the s@uh@ufexisted in the times of 'Uthmān (rta) before his martyrdom and it was later either lifted from there or was destroyed and that Yazīd ibn 'Ubayd saw this mus@h@afbefore 'Uthmān's martyrdom, then this is historically not possible: it is known that Yazīd ibn 'Ubayd died in 147 AH[14] and 'Uthmān (rta) was assassinated in 36 AH.[15] So if it is supposed that Yazīd was ten or twelve years old at that time, this would mean that Yazīd would actually have to be about 125 or years old or perhaps even older to come see this mus@h@af– something that is highly improbable. This is because narrators whose ages exceed 100 are often indicated among the mu'ammarūn by the authorities of rijāl.

'Imādī also contends that just as it is not possible for this incident to have taken place before the martyrdom of 'Uthmān (rta) for reasons just stated, it is equally improbable for the box to have been left there intact after his martyrdom.

III. Critical Analysis

It can be seen from the foregoing section that there are two distinct opinions about the mus@h@afwhich was placed near a specific pillar of the Prophet's mosque where Salamah ibn al-Akwa' (d. 74 AH) and Yazīd ibn Abī 'Ubayd (d. 147 AH) would come and the latter would observe the former seeking out that pillar.

Scholars like al-'Ayni (d. 855 AH),[16] al-Qast@alānī (d. 923 AH) and al-Kashmīrī (d. 1352 AH) are of the opinion that this was one of the mas@ah@ifprepared by 'Uthmān (rta) and was kept by him in the Prophet's mosque. It continued to be there after 'Uthmān's martyrdom right up to the period when Yazīd ibn Abī 'Ubayd saw Salamah ibn al-Akwa' seeking out that place to pray there since Salamah had observed the Prophet (sws) seeking out this place for the prayer

'Imādī, on the other hand, is of the opinion that this was the mus@h@afwhich was prepared at the behest of the Prophet (sws) and placed at his mosque right after migration. It was however later withdrawn to H@afs@ah's house and subsequently destroyed by Marwān ibn H@akam. However, the pillar near which it was placed in a box was a sought after place by the Prophet (sws) to pray. The prophet thinking it to be a blessed place would go and pray at this place after it had been withdrawn. Later, this practice of seeking out this place was adhered to by Salamah ibn al-Akwa' and perhaps some other companions. Yazīd ibn Abī 'Ubayd who was a freed slave of Salamah observed his former master seeking out this place to pray.

As far as the first of these opinions is concerned, it obviously can only imply that a mus@h@afwas placed in 'Uthmānic times near the pillar where the Prophet (sws) prayed. Salamah ibn al-Akwa' would seek out that place to pray not because the mus@h@af was placed there but because the Prophet (sws) had reserved this place for offering the prayer.[17]

The basic question which arises on this view is that there is perhaps not a single corroboration of this found in early Muslim history. If one of the mas@āh@ifmade by 'Uthmān (rta) was placed in the mosque of the Prophet (sws) and remained there for almost four to five decades till the time Yazī ibn Abī 'Ubayd witnessed it, it should have been big news for historians to report. It can be supposed that Yazīd was referring to the pillar near which an 'Uthmānic mus@h@afwas once found but in his own time it was not there and that he just referred to it by saying that this was the pillar near which an 'Uthmānic mus@h@afwas once placed. Again this supposition requires corroboration from history. No source of history mentions that an 'Uthmānic mus@h@afonce placed near a pillar of the Prophet's mosque was later withdrawn from that place.

As far as the second of these opinions is concerned, the following questions arise on it:

i. There is no corroboratory source which says that the leaves of the Qur'ān were placed at one time in the mosque of the Prophet (sws) after the latter's migration to Madīnah and later withdrawn to Hafs@ah's house for reasons stated by 'Imādī.

ii. It is concluded by 'Imādī that every time a portion of the Qur'ān was revealed, these leaves would be recalled from Hafs@ah's custody, the newly revealed verses inserted in them, companions would copy the newly revealed verses in their own codices and then they were returned back to H@afs@ah's care. Now the leaves moving back and forth from Hafs@ah's custody at the instance of a new revelation and the companions copying the new revelation from these leaves is a very prominent event. This activity should have been reported by many people. On the contrary, we do not have a single report on it.

iii. Sources do say that after Abū Bakr's death, the s@uh@ufcollected by him remained in the custody of 'Umar (rta) and after his death they came into the custody of H@afs@ah (rta) (which is almost twelve years) after the Prophet's death. But there is not a single report or source which says that H@afs@ah (rta) possessed the leaves of the Prophet's Qur'ān in his lifetime. Even the narrative cited by 'Imādī with reference to Muh@ammad ibn 'Uthmān ibn Abī Shaybah's Fad@ā'il al-Qur'ānshows that H@afs@ah (rta) never had these leaves in the lifetime of the Prophet (sws) and only came to possess these leaves after 'Umar's death.

iv. On the one hand, 'Imādī regards the narratives of the collections of the Qur'ān under Abū Bakr (rta) and 'Uthmān (rta) as fabrications and on the other, the narrative he cites to establish his view relates almost the same sequence of events as these fabricated narratives. This is evident, in particular, in his mention of the fact that H@afs@ah's s@uh@ufwere summoned by 'Uthmān (rta) in his time.

v. The narrative cited by 'Imādī is itself not soundly established for the following reasons.

a. There is no other source which calls these leaves umm.

b. The narrative contains the following suspect narrators:

-- Ismā'īl ibn 'Abd al-Rah@mān al-Suddī al-Kabīr. About him Al-Mizzī records: Yah@yā ibn Ma'īn and 'Abd al-Rah@mān ibn Mahdī regard him to be d@a'īf; al-Sa'dī says that he is a great liar and abuses [the companions]; Abū Zur'ah says he is layyin@; Abū H@ātim says: yuktabu h@adīthuhū wa lā yuh@tajju bihī.[18]

-- Muh@ammad ibn 'Uthmān ibn Abī Shaybah is suspect in the eyes of some authorities.Although some authorities have regarded him to be trustworthy, here is what Ibn H@ajar[19] records about him: 'Abdullāh ibn Ah@mad ibn H@anbal, 'Abdullāh ibn 'Usāmah al-Kalbī, Ibrāhīm ibn Ish@āq al-S@awwāf and Dā'ūd ibn Yah@yā say that he is a great liar and Ibn Khirāsh says that he fabricates narratives. Ja'far ibn Muh@ammad al-T@ayālisī says that not only is he a great liar, he attributes to people narrations which are never reported by those who have actually heard them.

-- 'Uthmān ibn Muh@ammad ibn Abī Shaybah(who is the father of the aforementioned narrator) has been mentioned by al-'Uqaylī in his al-D@u'afā'[20]and Ibn H@ajar's opinion about him is lahū awhām.[21]

These details about the narrators of the report challenge its sound ascription to Anas ibn Mālik (rta) to whom it is attributed.

vi. The linguistic argument presented by 'Imādī to prove his point that these leaves were withdrawn is not decisive. Even if his interpretation of a suppression of the word موضع(place) before المصحفis accepted, there is no essential difference between the expressions: الأسطوانة التي عند المصحف(the pillar near the mus@h@af) and الأسطوانة التي عند موضع المصحف(the pillar near the place of the mus@h@af). The latter does not necessarily mean that the mus@h@afhad been withdrawn and that the place at which it was placed was empty and that it was this vacated place where the Prophet (sws) prayed. Linguistically, these words can also mean that the Prophet (sws) prayed at the place beside the pillar near which the mus@h@afwas placed. It is not necessary to assume that the mus@h@af was not present there – for he was not praying exactly at the place of the mus@h@af; he was praying at a place near the pillar beside which the mus@h@afwas placed.

V Further Discussion

Which then is the mus@h@afreferred to in the narratives under discussion if it is neither an 'Uthmānic Qur'ān as opined 'Aynī, Qast@alānī and Kashmīirī nor that of the Prophet (sws) that was placed near a pillar of his mosque and later withdrawn as opined by 'Imādī?

A study of history shows that al-H@ajjāj ibn Yūsuf (d. 95 AH) introduced the practice of having the Qur'an read collectively by people in the mosques at specific times from its written copies placed in the mosques. Thus, various authorities report the following opinion of Imām Mālik in this regard:

Al-Shāt@ibī (d. 790 AH) records:

قال مالك أول من جعل مصحفا الحجاج بن يوسف يريد انه اول من رتب القراءة في المصحف اثر صلاة الصبح في المسجد

Mālik said: "The first person to introduce the practice of reading from the mus@h@afafter the morning prayer was al-H@ajjāj ibn Yūsuf."[22]

Ibn Rajab (d. 795 AH) records:

وقال ابن وهب سمعت مالكا يقول لم تكن القراءة في المسجد من أمر الناس القديم و أول من أحدث في المسجد الحجاج بن يوسف قال مالك وأنا أكره ذلك الذي يقرأ في المسجد في المصحف وقد روى هذا كله أبو بكر النيسابوري في كتاب مناقب مالك رحمه الله

Ibn Wahb said that he heard Mālik say: "Reading out [the Qur'ān] in the mosque was not a practice of the people in the earliest times. The first person to introduce it in the mosque was al-H@ajjāj ibn Yūsuf. I do not approve of what is read in the mosque from the mus@h@af." And all this narrated by Abū Bakr al-Nīsāburī in Kitāb Manāqib-i Mālik.[23]

History recounts that al-H@ajjāj ibn Yūsuf sent copies to various mosques so that the practice of reading out from them could be initiated. Al-Qalqashandī specifies that this sending of the mas@āh@ifby al-H@ajjāj took place in 76 AH.[24]

The anecdote of two of them has survived: a copy to the Prophet's mosque at Madīnah and another one sent to Egypt to the mosque of 'Amr ibn al-'Ās in the city of Fust@āt@@.[25] The copy sent to the Prophet's mosque at Madīnah was placed on the right side of the pillar which was a sign of the place where the Prophet (sws) stood in prayer. Ibn Zabālah (d. 199 AH) records:

قال ابن زبالة : حدثني مالك بن أنس قال : أرسل الحجاج بن يوسف إلى أمهات القرى بمصاحف ، فأرسل إلى المدينة بمصحف منها كبير ، وهو أول من أرسل بالمصاحف إلى القرى ، وكان هذا المصحف في صندوق عن يمين الأسطوانة التي عملت علما لمقام النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم ، وكان يفتح في يوم الجمعة والخميس ، ويقرأ فيه إذا صليت الصبح ، فبعث المهدي بمصاحف لها أثمان فجعلت في صندوق و نحي منها مصحف الحجاج ، فوضعت عن يسار السارية ، ووضعت منابر لها كانت تقرأ عليها ، وحمل مصحف الحجاج في صندوقه فجعل عند الأسطونة التي عن يمين المنبر

Ibn Zabālah reports from Mālik ibn Anas: "Al-H@ajjāj ibn Yūsuf sent mas@āh@ifto all major cities. Amongst these, he sent a large mus@h@afto Madīnah and he was the first one to send the mas@āh@ifto the cities. This mus@h@afwas in a box that was placed to the right of the pillar which was a sign of the place where the Prophet stood [in prayer]. It would be opened on every Thursday and Friday and would be read after the morning prayer. Al-Mahdī then sent mas@āh@ifwhich were very expensive and they were put in a box which was placed near the left of this pillar and pulpits were constructed on which it was read. At the same time, the mus@h@afof al-H@ajjāj was displaced from its place and carried and placed near the pillar which was to right of the [main] pulpit."[26]

Furthermore, 'Umar ibn Shabbah (d. 262 AH) records:

قال وأخبرني عبد العزيز بن عمران عن محرز بن ثابت مولى مسلمة بن عبد الملك عن أبيه قال كنت في حرس الحجاج بن يوسف فكتب الحجاج المصاحف ثم بعث بها إلى الأمصار وبعث بمصحف إلى المدينة فكره ذلك آل عثمان فقيل لهم أخرجوا مصحف عثمان يقرأفقالوا أصيب المصحف بوم قتل عثمان رضى الله عنهقال محرز بلغني أن مصحف عثمان بن عفان صار إلى خالد بن عمرو بن عثمان قال فلما استخلف المهدي بعث بمصحف إلى المدينة فهو الذي يقرأ فيه اليوم وعزل مصحف الحجاج فهو في الصندوق الذي دون المنبر

Muhriz ibn Thābit reports from his father: "I was among the guards of al-H@ajjāj ibn Yūsuf. He wrote the mas@āh@ifand then sent them to various cities and sent a mus@h@afto Madīnah. The family of 'Uthmān (rta) did not like this. They were asked: 'Hand over the mus@h@afof 'Uthmān so that it can be read.' They replied: 'It was destroyed the day 'Uthmān was assassinated.'" Muhriz said: "The report has reached me that the mus@h@afcame into the possession of Khālid ibn 'Amr ibn 'Uthmān. When al-Mahdī became the caliph, he sent a mus@h@afto Madīnah. This is the one which is being read these days. He displaced the mus@h@afof H@ajjāj which was in a box behind the pulpit."[27]

VI Conclusion

On the basis of the foregoing details, it can be concluded with reasonable certainty that the mus@h@afreferred to in the narrative under discussion was the one which al-H@ajjāj ibn Yūsuf sent to the Prophet's mosque in Madīnah and which was placed besides the pillars where the Prophet Muh@ammad (sws) would offer his optional prayers. It can neither be the Prophet's mus@h@afnor one of the copies prepared by 'Uthmān. (rta).

______________

[1]. Abū 'Abdullāh Muh@ammad ibn Ismā'īlal-Bukhārī, Al-Jāmi' al-s@ah@īh@, 3rd ed., vol. 1 (Beirut: Dār Ibn Kathīr, 1987), 189, (no. 480). See also: Abū al-H@usaynMuslim ibn al-H@ajjāj al-Qushayrī, Al-Jāmi' al-s@ah@īh@, vol. 1 (Beirut: Dār ih@yā' al-turāth al-'arabī, n.d.), 364, (no. 509); Abū 'Abdullāh Muh@ammad ibn Sa'd al-Zuhrī.Al-T@abaqāt al-kubrā, vol. 4 (Beirut: Dār S@ādir, n.d.), 307; Abū Nu'aymAh@mad ibn 'Abdullah ibn Ah@mad ibn Ish@āq ibn Mūsā ibn Mihrān al-As@bahānī., Al-Musnad al-mustakhraj 'alā S@ah@īh@Muslim, 1st ed., vol. 2 (Beirut: Dār al-kutub al-'ilmiyyah, 1996), 116,(no. 1124); Ah@mad ibn H@anbal, Musnad, vol. 4 (Egypt: Mu'assasah al-Qurt@ubah, n.d.), 48, (no. 16564); Ibid., vol. 4, 54, (16590); Abū Bakr Ah@mad ibn al-H@usaynal-Bayhaqī, Al-Sunan al-kubrā, vol. 2 (Makkah: Maktabah Dār al-Bāz, 1994), 271, (no. 3284); Ibid., vol. 5, 247, (no. 10063); Abū al-Qāsim Sulaymān ibn Ah@madal-T@abarānī, Al-Mu'jam al-kabīr, 2nd ed., vol. 7, (Maws@il: Maktabah al-zahrā', 1983), 34, (no. 6299), Abū H@ātim Muh@ammad ibn H@ibbān al-Bustī, S@ah@īh@, 2nd ed., vol. 5 (Beirut: Mu'assasah al-risālah, 1993) 59, (no. 1763); Ibid., vol. 5, 526, (no. 2152); Abū 'Abdullāh Muh@ammad ibn Yazīd al-Qazwīnī ibn Mājah, Sunan, vol. 1 (Beirut: Dār al-fikr, n.d.), 459, (no. 1430); Abū Bakr Muh@ammad ibn Hārūn al-Ru'yānī, Musnad, 1st ed., vol. 2 (Cairo: Mu'assasah Qurt@ubah, 1416 AH) , 249, (no. 1142); Abū Muh@ammad ibn Ah@mad al-Barzālī, Mashyakhah Abī Bakr ibn Ah@mad ibn 'Abd al-Dā'im al-Maqdisī, 1st ed., vol. 1 (Damascus, Dā al-Bashā'ir, 1997), 46, (no. 18); Muh@ammad ibn Zabālah, Akhbār al-Madīnah, 1st ed. (Madīnah: Markaz buh@ūth wa dirasāt al-Madīnah al-Munawwarah, 1424 AH), 124.

[2].See, respectivelyBadr al-Dīn Mah@mūd ibn Ah@mad ibn Mūsā ibn Ah@mad al-'Aynī, 'Umdah al-qarī sharh@S@ah@īh@al-Bukhārī, vol 4 (Beirut: Dār ih@yā al-turāth al-'arabī, n.d.), 283; Abū al-'Abbās Shihāb al-Dīn Ah@mad ibn Muh@ammadal-Qast@alānī, Irshād al-sārī li sharh@i S@ah@īh@al-Bukhārī, vol. 1 (Cairo: Al-Mat@ba ' al-kubrā al-amīriyyah, 1323 AH), 467; Muh@ammad Anwar Shāh al-Kashmīrī, Fayd@al-Bārī'alā S@ah@īh@al-Bukhārī, vol. 2 (Quetta: Al-Maktabah al-rashīdiyyah, n.d.), 81.

[3].Tamanna 'Imādī, Jam' al-Qur'ān, 2nd ed. (Karachi: al-Rah@mān Publishing Trust, 1994), 398-424.

[4]. Literally: al-s@andūq. This word does not occur in any of the extant versions of H@adīth anthologies. However, the text of S@ah@īh@Muslimbefore Ibn H@ajar mentions that this mus@h@afwas placed in a box (s@andūq) and placed near a pillar of the mosque. See: Abū al-Fad@l Ah@mad ibn 'Alī ibn H@ajar, al-'Asqalānī, Fath@al-Bārī, 4th ed. (Beirut: Dār ih@yā' al-turāth al-'arabī, 1988), 457.

[5].'Imādī has referred to a hand written manuscript of this book found in personal collection of a Qādī Rad@ā H@usayn of Patna and cited page 32 of the manuscript.

[6]. Ah@mad ibn H@anbal, Musnad, vol. 4, 54, (no. 16590).

[7]. Praying at this spot is mentioned in the narrative of al-Bukhārī.

[8]. The extant versions of Muslim's Al-Jāmi' al-s@ah@īh@do not have these words. 'Imādī also refers to this fact. The words they have are:

[9]. Ibn H@ajar, Fath@al-Bārī, vol. 1, 457.

[10]. Al-Bukhārī, Al-Jāmi' al-s@ah@īh@, vol. 1, 189, (no. 480).

[11]. Ah@mad ibn H@anbal, Musnad, vol. 4, 54, (16590).

[12]. Muslim, Al-Jāmi' al-s@ah@@īh@@, vol. 1, 364 (no. 509).

[13]. 'Imādī gives no reference as to which version of 'Aynī had these words. It may be pointed out that in the extant version, the words are :

( التي عند المصحف) هذا يدل على أنه كان في مسجد رسول الله موضع خاص للمصحف الذي كان ثمة من عهد عثمان

The expression: [the pillar] near the mus@h@af] signifies that in the mosque of the messenger of God, there was a special place for the mus@h@afwhich was there since the times of 'Uthmān. (Al-'Aynī, 'Umdah al-qārī, vol. 4, 283)

[14]. Abū al-H@ajjāj Yūsuf ibn al-Zakī al-Mizzī, Tahdhīb al-kamāl fī asmā' al-rijāl, 1st ed., vol 32 (Beirut: Mu'assasah al-risālah, 1980), 206.

[15]. To be exact, his death actually occurred in the last month of 35 AH. See: Al-Mizzī, Tahdhīb al-kamāl, vol. 19, 454;Abū al-Fad@l Ah@mad ibn 'Alī ibn H@ajar, al-'Asqalānī, Taqrīb al-tahdhīb, 1st ed. (Syria: Dār al-rashīd, 1986), 385.

[16]. This is assuming that the words in 'Aynī's commentary were the ones found in the extant version of his commentary; ie. كان في مسجد رسول الله موضع خاص للمصحف الذي كان ثمة من عهد عثمان(in the mosque of the messenger of God, there was a special place for the mus@h@afwhich was there since the times of 'Uthmān.) See: Al-'Aynī, 'Umdah al-qārī, vol. 4, 283.

[17]. Otherwise it would lead to the absurd scenario of a mus@h@afof 'Uthmān (rta) being present in the Prophet's mosque and the Prophet (sws) seeking out the place where it was placed so that he could pray there.

[18]. Al-Mizzī, Tahdhīb al-kamāl, vol. 3, 135-137.

[19]. Abū al-Fad@l Ah@mad ibn 'Alī ibn H@ajar, al-'Asqalānī, Lisān al-mīzān, vol. 5 (Beirut: Mu'assasah al-a'lamī li al-mat@bū'āt, 1986), 280.

[20]. Abū Ja'far Muh@ammad ibn 'Umar ibn Mūsā al-'Uqaylī, Al-D@u'afā' al-kabīr, 1sted., vol 3 (Beirut: Dār al-kutub al-'ilmiyyah,1984), 222.

[21]. Ibn H@ajar, Taqrīb al-tahdhīb, 386.

[22]. Abū Ish@āq Ibrāhīm ibn Mūsā ibn Muh@ammad al-Shāt@ibī, Al-I'tis@ām, vol. 1 (Egypt: Al-Maktabah al-tujāriyyah al-kubrā, n.d.), 172.

[23]. Abū al-Farj Zayn al-Dīn 'Abd al-Rah@mān ibn Shihāb al-Dīn ibn Rajab al-Baghdādī, Jāmi' al-'ulūm wa al-h@ikam fī sharh@khamsīn h@adīthan@min jawāmi' al-kalim, 7th ed. (Beirut: Mu'assasah al-risālah, 1417 AH), 345. Al-Samhūdī (d. 911 AH) records Imām Mālik's aversion to this practice by citing the fact that Mālik would like people be made to disperse from the mosques where they would gather to read out the Qur'ān jointly.See: Nūr al-Dīn 'Alī ibn Ah@mad al-Samhūdī, Wafā' al-wafā bi akhbār dār al-mus@t@afā, vol. 2 (Beirut: Dār al-kutub al-'ilmiyyah, n.d.), 198. While explaining this intensity on the part of Imām Mālik, Ibn Rushd says that this relates to persistently reading out the Qur'ān jointly after a specific prayer so that this practice comes to be regarded as a sunnah – in the way it is being observed (in his times) after the morning prayer at the mosque of Cordova. See: Al-Shāt@ibī, Al-I'tis@ām, vol. 2, 30; Abū Ish@āq Ibrāhīm ibn Mūsā ibn Muh@ammad al-Shāt@ibī, Al-Muwāfaqāt fī us@ūl al-fiqh, vol. 2(Beirut: Dār al-ma'rifah, n.d.), 213.

[24]. Ah@mad ibn 'Alī. S@ubh@ al a'shā fī s@ina'ah al-inshāal-Qalqashandī, vol. 3 (Damascus: Wizārah al-thaqāfah, 1981), 383.

[25]. It may be of interest to note that the copy sent by al-H@ajjāj to Egypt was met with resentment by 'Abd al-'Azīz ibn Marwān (d. 86 AH), the then governor of Egypt and brother of the reigning caliph 'Abd al-Malik ibn Marwān. He refused to accept this copy from a less ranking officer (ie al-H@ajjāj) of the empire. This incident induced him to prepare a copy for his region; the copy was prepared and housed in his own residence. It would be taken to the mosque every Friday and read out and then transported back. It came to be known as the mus@h@afof Asmā' (d. 118 AH) (a grand daughter of 'Abd al-'Azīz ibn Marwān). Those who have recorded this incident with various details include, Ibn 'Abd al-H@akam (d. 247 AH), Ibn Duqmāq (d. 809 AH) (on the authority of 'Abd al-Rah@mān ibn Ah@mad ibn Yūnus al-Mis@rī (d. 347 AH))and al-Maqrīzī (d. 845 AH) (on the authority of Abū 'Abdullāh Muh@ammad ibn Salāmah ibn Ja'far al-Qud@ā'ī (d. 454 AH)). For details, see respectively: Abū al-Qāsim 'Abd al-Rah@mān ibn 'Abdullāh 'Abd al-H@akam ibn A'yun al-Qarshī al-Mis@rī, Futūh@-i Mis@r wa akhbāruhā, 1st ed. (Beirut: Dār al-fikr, 1416 AH), 217; Ibrāhīm ibn Muh@ammad ibn Duqmāq, Kitāb al-intis@ār li wāsitah 'iqd al-ams@ār, vol, 4 (Būlāq: Al-Mat@ba'ah al-kubrā amīriyah, 1309 AH), 72; Taqī al-Dīn Ah@mad ibn 'Alī ibn 'Abd al-Qādir ibn Muh@ammad al-Maqrīzī, Al-Mawā'iz@wa al-i'tibār bi al-dhikr al-khit@at@wa al-āthār, vol. 3 (Cairo: Maktabah madbūlā, 1998), 164. Among modern historians, see: al-Barrī, Qur'ān wa 'ulūmuhū fī Mis@r, 62-73.

[26]. Muh@ammad ibn Zabālah, Akhbār al-Madīnah, 124. It may be of interest to note that Ibn al-Najjār (d. 643 AH) quotes almost exactly the same text as above (with some additions at the end) but ascribes it directly to Imām Mālik and does not mention Ibn Zabālah as an intermediate narrator. See: Abū 'Abdullāh Muh@ammad ibn Mah@mūd ibn al-Najjār al-Baghdādī, Al-Durrah al-thamīnah fī akhbār al-madīnah (Beirut: Shirkah dār al-arqam ibn abī al-arqam, n.d.), 118-119.

[27]. 'Umar ibn Shabbah, Tārīkh al-Madīnah (Beirut: Dār al-kutub al-'ilmiyyah, 1996), vol. 1, 9.




Articles by this author


Successful Parents

The “Successful Spouse” Test

Let us Value what We have

Dear Husbands … If I may say!

The “Blind Drill”

Life goes on all the same!

Prayers can Move Mountains!

Two types of “Junk Food”

Reforming Our Conduct

Supplications from the Hadith

Supplications from the Qur’an

A Small Act of Kindness

Respecting the Privacy of our Mature Children

Explanation of Some Jarh Terms

Selections from Hadith

Your Questions Answered

Two Tough Trials

Benefiting from Criticism

Your Questions Answered

The Cause of Truth

Your Questions Answered

Selections from Hadith

Restraining our Wounded Pride

Selections from Hadith

The Power of One

Preparing for the Inevitable!

Selections from Hadith

Let us Refuse to Lose!

The Sound of Silence

Selections from Hadith

Let us Enjoy every Moment of our Lives

Lets be Just, Come what May!

Selections from Hadith

Beware of the three C’s: Cynicism, Criticism and Complaint

Never Give Up!

Do We have a Spiritual Part of the Day?

Tears of Old Parents … for their Children

Life goes on all the same!

The Decorum of Criticizing Others

Tears that would not stop!

Selections from Hadith

Hobbies we must have!

Death in Innocence

“Thank you” Culture

Visit to an Old Home

We Owe it to Our Society

Experiencing God

Discovering our Inner Talent

The Battle for Honesty Continues!

Saintly Sinners

Secret to Inner Peace

Your Questions Answered

Small Acts of Kindness

Illness can be a Boon!

Philosophy of Animal Sacrifice on ‘Id

Tears of Gratitude!

Lookout to Leap for Others!

Charity

Turning Foes into Friends

Let us then Live for Others!

SPECIAL ISSUE

A Re-Evaluation of Early Developments in Qur’anic Orthography (1/4)

A Re-Evaluation of Early Developments in Qur’anic Orthography (2/4)

A Re-Evaluation of Early Developments in Qur’anic Orthography (3/4)

A Re-Evaluation of Early Developments in Qur’anic Orthography (4/4)

Abdus Sattar Ghauri (The Father Figure of Al-Mawrid!)

Brief Profile

Special Issue

Charity: Points to Ponder

Your Question Answered

“Dignity in Hard Labour Lies!”

Forgiveness

Never Lose Hope!

The Trials of Life

Anger Management

Handling Mature Children

Let us Promise…

An Introduction to Ghāmidī’s Mīzān

Visit to a Graveyard

Are We Ready to Die?

A Shame to Humanity[1]!

A Critical Evaluation of Variations found in the ‘Uthmānic Copies (Part 4/4)

A Critical Evaluation of Variations found in the ‘Uthmānic Copies (Part 3/4)

A Critical Evaluation of Variations found in the ‘Uthmānic Copies (Part 2/4)

A Critical Evaluation of Variations found in the ‘Uthmānic Copies (Part 1/4)

The Key to Successful Marriage

Taming the Tongue

Sexual Intimacy between Husband and Wife

Pretension and Pomposity

The Cause of Truth

Narrative on the Changes made in the Qur’ān by al-Hajjāj ibn Yūsuf

Sūrah Mā’idah (64-89)

Sympathy

A Man of Steel

Critical Evaluation of Ustuwānah al-Mushaf Narratives

Humility

Fasting in Extreme Conditions

How to overcome Selfishness

Nothing but the Truth, Please!

Narratives on the Collection of the Qur’ān by ‘Alī(rta) (part 1/3)

Narratives on the Collection of the Qur’ān by ‘Alī(rta) (part 2/3)

Narratives on the Collection of the Qur’ān by ‘Alī(rta) (part 3/3)

A Tribute to Brig (retd.) Noor Ahmed Husain (Quaid e Azam’s Last Military ADC)

Courage

Appendix C: A Brief Biographical Sketch of Hamīd al-Dīn al-Farāhī (1863-1930) [1]

Appendix B:  A Brief Summary of the Views of Traditional and Radical Western Scholars

Appendix A:  A Summary of the View of Traditional Muslim Scholars

A Critical Evaluation of Farahī’s View on the Collection of the Qur’ān

A Citizen of Paradise (Written on the Martyrdom of Dr Habib ur Rahman)

Forgiveness

Gratitude

Your Questions Answered

Reason and Revelation

Your Questions Answered

Explanation of Some Qur’ānic Words

Explanation of Some Jarh Terms

The Warrior who became a Martyr

A Narrative on the Placement of Sūrah Anfāl (8) and…

A Critical Analysis of the Narratives on the… (Part 1/2)

A Critical Analysis of the Narratives on the… (Part 2/2)

Your Questions Answered

Travelling Alone!

A Narrative on the Schematic Arrangement of the Qur’ān (Part 2/2)

A Narrative on the Schematic Arrangement of the Qur’ān (Part 1/2)

The Word Rusul in the Qur’ān

Your Questions Answered

Mustafā A‘zamī’s Critique on “The Dishonest Scribe” Narratives

A Passionate Preacher of the Qur’an passes away!

Animal Sacrifice

… And the List is Unending!

English Translation of the first volume of Tadabbur-i Qur’ān

Sūrah Ghāshiyah

Your Questions Answered

Jihād in the Qur’ān

Your Questions Answered

Your Questions Answered

Morals and Morality

Faith and Beliefs

The Religion of Islam

Coping with Sexual Desires at Adolescence

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (X)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (IX)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (VIII)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (VII)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (VI)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (V)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (IV)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (III)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (II)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (I)