Freedom of Will, Determinism & Fatalism

Freedom of Will, Determinism & Fatalism


If man is to be held accountable for his deeds, it is essential that he be free to do right and wrong, if all his actions are predestined then he should not be held responsible for any of them. The Quran gives a definite answer to this, but before we do present it, let us first see how some of our philosophers view this question which has puzzled many a mind.

Pythagoras thought that the universe is like a machine with various parts. Man is also a part of this whole. No part of a machine has a will of its own. According to Heraclitinst the universe is a huge combination of unchanging physical laws. These laws are also working on man and therefore is no question of free will. Zeno maintained that everything that happens has a cause. Whatever man does is actually an effect of senses that are distinctly separate from his actions -- therefore there is no will at all. Voltaire was of the opinion that if free will is not complete and absolute, then there is no free will and it is quite obvious that men does not have absolute free will.


According to the Quran, the matter should be understood by introspection rather than entrospection.

There is no free will for man regarding his physical self, environment and events external to himself. But he has been given free will in a limited circle. And this is where he would be held accountable on the judgement day. He is only free in his intention (2:30) (intentions as opposed to desired). As per his freedom in actions or converting intentions into actions is concerned, man has a defacto freedom to that as well, but not dejure. Then as man has freedom in intentions therefore his accountability would be on the basis of his intentions. The test of man is that with this freedom in intention, whether he intends for good or evil.

There has been a lot of debate as to what is good and what is evil among thinkers and philosophers. The Quran states that man knows what is good and what is evil, and this, according to the Quran, is an Apriori knowledge:

But infact man is a witness over himself, however much an excuse he tenders. (75:14-15)

Have We not made for him a pair of eyes and a tongue and a pair of lips? And shown him both the paths?' (90:8-10)

Hence, if (soul) was enlightened as to its right and wrong. (91:8)

Another question in this respect is that who is the creator of good and evil? The Quran states that actually there is only one real value, that of good. Evil is only the result of providing man with freedom in intention. When, on the basis of his free will, he opts to avoid good, evil comes into being.


Articles by this author

Two Blows Allowed to the Hellfire

The Real Criterion in Prohibition of Drinks

Praying for the Prophet (sws) after Adhan

A Narrative regarding Man’s Potential of Goodness after Accepting Islam

A Narrative about the Prophet’s Directive regarding the Appropriate Clothing for Women

The Prophet’s Warning about Chaotic Times

Qualities of Various Tribes and Nations

The Prophet’s Lack of Authority to Prohibit what God has kept Lawful

The Best of the Arabian Women

A Prediction regarding the Muslim Rules after the Prophet (sws)

Fulfilling the Vow of a Deceased Mother

Punishment for Apostates

The Prophet’s Time for Zuhr Prayers during Summers and Winters

Seasonal Variations in Prayer Timings

Urging People to Attend Congregational Prayers

The Deadline for Fajr and ‘Asr Prayers

A Comprehensive Directive in Islam

When one is Late in Joining the Congregational Prayers…

The Obligatory Religious Practices of Islam

Two Blows Allowed to the Hellfire

Praying for the Prophet (sws) after Adhan

The Prophet (sws) does not have the Authority to Prohibit what God has kept Lawful

Eating Garlic, Onion and Leek in Cooked Form

An Etiquette relating to Visiting the Mosque

True Muslim, Mu’min, Mujahid and Muhajir

The Time for the ‘Āsr Prayer

Urging People to Attend the Congregational Prayers

The Prophet’s Experience of Revelation

What should a Person say when he hears the Adhān?

Delaying Zuhr Prayer in Intense Heat

Ascertaining the Time-Range for each Prayer

True Muslim, Mu’min, Mujāhid & Muhājir

The Obligatory Religious Practices of Islam

The Real Criterion in Prohibition of Drinks

The Significance of Intention Behind Good Deeds

What is the Punishment for Adultery?

Do the Errors in the Bible Disprove the Divinity of the Qur’an?

Can Angels Disobey?

Solomon (sws) Listening to Ants

Could Allah have a Son?

The Position of Jesus (sws) in the Hereafter

Marrying the Wives of Adopted Sons

Who is the Father of Jesus (sws)?

Abrogation and the Unalterable Word of God

Will Christians enter Paradise or go to Hell?

Is the Qur’an Clear or Incomprehensible?

Self Purification and the Forgotten Ideal

Is Islam a Divine Religion?

Wine – Good or Bad?

Did Abraham (sws) Smash the Idols?

The Infinite Loop Problem

Surah Fatihah

Quick or Slow Creation?

Corruption in the Bible: The Muslim Stance

Schools of Religious Education (II)

Schools of Religious Education

Reason and Revelation

Freedom of Will, Determinism & Fatalism