Mustafā A‘zamī’s Critique on “The Dishonest Scribe” Narratives

Mustafā A‘zamī’s Critique on “The Dishonest Scribe” Narratives


Hadith

It is reported in some narratives that there were three scribes who would deliberately alter the revelation dictated to them by the Prophet (sws). The most prominent among them is 'Abdullāh ibn Sa'd ibn Abī Sarah. Al-Wāqidī (d. 207 AH) records:

قَالُوا: وَكَانَ عَبْدُ اللّهِ بْنُ سَعْدِ بْنِ أَبِى سَرْحٍ يَكْتُبُ لِرَسُولِ اللّهِ الْوَحْىَ فَرُبّمَا أَمْلَى عَلَيْهِ رَسُولُ اللّهِ سَمِيعٌ عَلِيمٌ فَيُكْتَبُ عَلِيمٌ حَكِيمٌ، فَيَقْرَأُ رَسُولُ اللّهِ فَيَقُولُ: كَذَلِكَ اللّهُ وَيُقِرّهُ، وَافْتُتِنَ، وَقَالَ: مَا يَدْرِى مُحَمّدٌ مَا يَقُولُ إنّى لأَكْتُبُ لَهُ مَا شِئْت، هَذَا الّذِى كَتَبْت يُوحَى إلَىّ كَمَا يُوحَى إلَى مُحَمّدٍ، وَخَرَجَ هَارِبًا مِنْ الْمَدِينَةِ إلَى مَكّةَ مُرْتَدّا، فَأَهْدَرَ رَسُولُ اللّهِ دَمَهُ يَوْمَ الْفَتْحِ

They said: " 'Abdullāh ibn Sa'd ibn Abī Sarah would write the revelation for the Prophet. So sometimes when the Prophet (sws) would ask him to write سَمِيعٌ عَلِيمٌم (God hears and knows everything), he would write عَليِمٌ حَكِيم (God knows everything and is wise). The Prophet (sws) would then recite to him and say: 'God has revealed it thus,' and he would leave the revelation intact. And this led Ibn Abī Sarah to a trial and he said: 'Muhammad does not know what he says; I write for him whatever I want; This what I write has been revealed to me just as it was revealed to Muhammad.' He then ran away from Madīnah to Makkah recanting Islam. The Messenger of God forgave his life on the day Makkah was conquered."[1]

Al-Ansārī records on the authority of Hishām ibn al-Kalbī (d. 204 AH):

وقال ابن الكلبي حبيب بن جذيمة بالتخفيفأسلم قبل الفتح وهاجر وكان يكتب الوحيقال غيره وهو أول من كتب لرسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم من قريشقال ثم ارتد ورجع إلى مكة وقالإني كنت أصرف محمدا حيث أريد كان يملي علي عَزِيْزٌ حَكِيْمٌ فأقول أو عَلِيْمٌ حَكِيْمٌ فيقول (كل صواب)

Ibn al-Kalbi said: "Habīb ibn Jazīmah ['Abdullah ibn Sa'd ibn Abī Sarah] embraced faith before the conquest of Makkah and migrated [to Madīnah]. And he would write divine revelation [or as per another view] he was the first to write for the Prophet (sws) from the Quraysh. He then recanted Islam and returned to Makkah and said: 'I would change [the dictation of Muhammad (sws)] to what I wanted. He would dictate: "عَزِيْزٌ حَكِيْمٌ." I would say: "or عَلِيْمٌ حَكِيْمٌ." At this, he replied: "Both are correct."'" [2]

Muhammad Mustafā A'zamī (b. 1931), a contemporary Islamic scholar, has critically evaluated these narratives. Presented below is a summary of his criticism.[3]

1. Foremost sources like Ibn Hishām[4] (218 AH), Ibn Sa'd[5] (d. 230 AH), Khalīfah ibn Khayyāt[6](d. 240 AH)and al-Tabarī[7] (d. 310 AH) do not mention this tampering of Ibn Abī Sarah. All they mention is that he was a scribe who later recanted Islam.

It may also be added to this point of criticism made by A'zamī that Abū Dā'ūd (d. 275 AH)[8] and al-Nasā'ī (d. 303 AH)[9] are also devoid of any mention of this tampering and only mention his apostasy. Furthermore, narratives which mention that 'Abdullāh ibn Sa'd ibn Abī Sarah tampered with Qur'ānic verses while writing them down do not have a complete chain of narration.[10]

2. The Prophet (sws) would always have the person read out to him the revelation he had written. So how can a wrongly written verse still be found.

3. How can it be believed that the Prophet (sws) would corroborate what the person had written when actually what had been revealed to him was something else?

4. If is it supposed that such an incident happened once, how can it be assumed that the Prophet (sws) would have persisted with him as a scribe once his mischief came to his notice?

5. Al-Wāqidī and Ibn Kalbī are untrustworthy narrators.

6. The same incident has been attributed to other persons besides him: among them are 'Abdullāh ibn Khatal and a Christian who had recanted Islam.[11]

While referring to 'Abdullāh ibn Khatal, Ibn Sayyid al-Nās records:

وروينا من طريق النزال بن سبرة عن علي قال كان ابنخطل يكتب قدام النبي صلّى الله عليه وسلّم فكان إذا نزل ‏ «‏ غفور رحيم ‏» ‏ كتب رحيم غفور وإذا نزل ‏ «‏ سميع عليم ‏» ‏ كتب عليم سميع‏.‏ وفيه فقال ابن خطل ما كنت أكتب إلا ما أريد ثم كفر ولحق بمكة

'Alī said: "Ibn Khatal would write in front of the Prophet. So when غفور رحيم would be revealed, he would write: رحيم غفور, and when سميع عليم would be revealed, he would write: عليم سميع." And in the same narrative Ibn Khatal said: "I would only write what I wanted." Then he became a disbeliever and ran away to Makkah.[12]

However, after mentioning his name, Ibn Sayyid al-Nās writes that the narrative has been misreported and that the person in question was actually 'Abdullāh ibn Sa'd ibn Abī Sarah.

A'zamī has referred to some more details about him in line with the view expressed by Ibn Sayyid al-Nās. He finally concludes on the basis of Ibn Ishāq that Ibn Khatal was never a scribe; he was made a tax-collector by the Prophet (sws) and was guilty of killing his innocent servant and he later recanted Islam.[13]




Articles by this author


God’s Domain

Let us Light up our Prayers!

Successful Parents

The “Successful Spouse” Test

Let us Value what We have

Dear Husbands … If I may say!

The “Blind Drill”

Life goes on all the same!

Prayers can Move Mountains!

Two types of “Junk Food”

Reforming Our Conduct

Supplications from the Hadith

Supplications from the Qur’an

A Small Act of Kindness

Respecting the Privacy of our Mature Children

Explanation of Some Jarh Terms

Selections from Hadith

Your Questions Answered

Two Tough Trials

Benefiting from Criticism

Your Questions Answered

The Cause of Truth

Your Questions Answered

Selections from Hadith

Restraining our Wounded Pride

Selections from Hadith

The Power of One

Preparing for the Inevitable!

Selections from Hadith

Let us Refuse to Lose!

The Sound of Silence

Selections from Hadith

Let us Enjoy every Moment of our Lives

Lets be Just, Come what May!

Selections from Hadith

Beware of the three C’s: Cynicism, Criticism and Complaint

Never Give Up!

Do We have a Spiritual Part of the Day?

Tears of Old Parents … for their Children

Life goes on all the same!

The Decorum of Criticizing Others

Tears that would not stop!

Selections from Hadith

Hobbies we must have!

Death in Innocence

“Thank you” Culture

Visit to an Old Home

We Owe it to Our Society

Experiencing God

Discovering our Inner Talent

The Battle for Honesty Continues!

Saintly Sinners

Secret to Inner Peace

Your Questions Answered

Small Acts of Kindness

Illness can be a Boon!

Philosophy of Animal Sacrifice on ‘Id

Tears of Gratitude!

Lookout to Leap for Others!

Charity

Turning Foes into Friends

Let us then Live for Others!

SPECIAL ISSUE

A Re-Evaluation of Early Developments in Qur’anic Orthography (1/4)

A Re-Evaluation of Early Developments in Qur’anic Orthography (2/4)

A Re-Evaluation of Early Developments in Qur’anic Orthography (3/4)

A Re-Evaluation of Early Developments in Qur’anic Orthography (4/4)

Abdus Sattar Ghauri (The Father Figure of Al-Mawrid!)

Brief Profile

Special Issue

Charity: Points to Ponder

Your Question Answered

“Dignity in Hard Labour Lies!”

Forgiveness

Never Lose Hope!

The Trials of Life

Anger Management

Handling Mature Children

Let us Promise…

An Introduction to Ghāmidī’s Mīzān

Visit to a Graveyard

Are We Ready to Die?

A Shame to Humanity[1]!

A Critical Evaluation of Variations found in the ‘Uthmānic Copies (Part 4/4)

A Critical Evaluation of Variations found in the ‘Uthmānic Copies (Part 3/4)

A Critical Evaluation of Variations found in the ‘Uthmānic Copies (Part 2/4)

A Critical Evaluation of Variations found in the ‘Uthmānic Copies (Part 1/4)

The Key to Successful Marriage

Taming the Tongue

Sexual Intimacy between Husband and Wife

Pretension and Pomposity

The Cause of Truth

Narrative on the Changes made in the Qur’ān by al-Hajjāj ibn Yūsuf

Sūrah Mā’idah (64-89)

Sympathy

A Man of Steel

Critical Evaluation of Ustuwānah al-Mushaf Narratives

Humility

Fasting in Extreme Conditions

How to overcome Selfishness

Nothing but the Truth, Please!

Narratives on the Collection of the Qur’ān by ‘Alī(rta) (part 1/3)

Narratives on the Collection of the Qur’ān by ‘Alī(rta) (part 2/3)

Narratives on the Collection of the Qur’ān by ‘Alī(rta) (part 3/3)

A Tribute to Brig (retd.) Noor Ahmed Husain (Quaid e Azam’s Last Military ADC)

Courage

Appendix C: A Brief Biographical Sketch of Hamīd al-Dīn al-Farāhī (1863-1930) [1]

Appendix B:  A Brief Summary of the Views of Traditional and Radical Western Scholars

Appendix A:  A Summary of the View of Traditional Muslim Scholars

A Critical Evaluation of Farahī’s View on the Collection of the Qur’ān

A Citizen of Paradise (Written on the Martyrdom of Dr Habib ur Rahman)

Forgiveness

Gratitude

Your Questions Answered

Reason and Revelation

Your Questions Answered

Explanation of Some Qur’ānic Words

Explanation of Some Jarh Terms

The Warrior who became a Martyr

A Narrative on the Placement of Sūrah Anfāl (8) and…

A Critical Analysis of the Narratives on the… (Part 1/2)

A Critical Analysis of the Narratives on the… (Part 2/2)

Your Questions Answered

Travelling Alone!

A Narrative on the Schematic Arrangement of the Qur’ān (Part 2/2)

A Narrative on the Schematic Arrangement of the Qur’ān (Part 1/2)

The Word Rusul in the Qur’ān

Your Questions Answered

Mustafā A‘zamī’s Critique on “The Dishonest Scribe” Narratives

A Passionate Preacher of the Qur’an passes away!

Animal Sacrifice

… And the List is Unending!

English Translation of the first volume of Tadabbur-i Qur’ān

Sūrah Ghāshiyah

Your Questions Answered

Jihād in the Qur’ān

Your Questions Answered

Your Questions Answered

Morals and Morality

Faith and Beliefs

The Religion of Islam

Coping with Sexual Desires at Adolescence

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (X)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (IX)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (VIII)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (VII)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (VI)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (V)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (IV)

Fifty Common Misconceptions about Islam (III)