Sir Syed Ahmad Khan

Sir Syed Ahmad Khan


Question: The president of the country, Field Marshal Ayub Khan recently declared the late Sir Syed Ahmed Khan to be a great leader, reformer and saviour of the Muslims. Do you agree with his opinion?

Answer: As for the late Sir Syed Ahmed Khan being a great leader, it is a fact and a reality that he was an eminent leader of the Muslim nation. He served the Muslims at a very critical juncture in history and with sincerity which is unparalleled in the recent past.

Due to his sincerity, he gathered around himself men of extremely high moral virtue, character and calibre. None of our other leaders, other than him, managed to bring together so many people with such competence and qualities – Shibli, Hali, Nadhir Ahmad, Muhsin al-Mulk, Waqar al-Mulk, to name just a few. Each one of them is a source of pride for all Muslims due to his knowledge and service to the nation. All of them supported Sir Syed and did so with great fidelity. Mawlana Shibli disagreed with some of his political ideology but, despite this, was so concerned of his sincerity to the nation that, when he heard of his passing away, in a letter, declared it a great national calamity.

My mentor Mawlana Farahi (may God have mercy on him) considered Sir Syed's Tafsir a fitnah but was a great admirer of his high character and honesty of purpose for the nation.

Though we have not met him, yet have heard many valuable accounts of his concern for the nation. That is why we consider him a very great leader of the Muslim nation. However, I am a bit wary of the terms "reformer" and "saviour." The meaning of these words varies from person to person, but to me according to the realistic meaning of these expressions, the saviour is only God Almighty and I consider reformers only those who have tried to correct the ills of the world in the way of the prophets.

Nevertheless, one should remember that Sir Syed Ahmad Khan was not only a leader of the Muslim nation, but an orator and a writer as well. In his day, he wrote responses to the objections on Islam and on the Prophet of Islam (sws) raised by English Orientalists and priests and also wrote an exegesis of the Qur'an with this in mind.

Now every knowledgeable person knows that orators are not always conversant with the rules and elements of the faith. They are primarily concerned with the questions and answers of their opponents and objectors. They sincerely believe it their duty to furnish a response to silence an objector if they come across an argument against Islam even though their answer may be far from reality. They also do not think it wrong to provide an incorrect explanation if they cannot answer criticism on Islam. An aspect of this weakness is that orators/ writers of every era have tried to fit Islam to the standards of wisdom of their time. When Greek philosophy spread in the Muslim world, some tried to fit Islam to its standards. When new western philosophy appeared some people tried to match it to its scale. The correct way to serve and promote Islam would have been to highlight Islam's wisdom as opposed to the perceived wisdom of every era. But not many can have the God cognition of Ghazali, the vision of Ibn Taymiyyah, the wisdom of Shah Waliullah nor the imagination of Allamah Iqbal. Could Sir Syed do better than the ordinary level in this field? In order to do something exceptional, profound knowledge of the philosophy of the time and understanding of Islamic affairs was required. As far as western thought and philosophy were concerned, he had no direct knowledge of them, just what he had heard. Similarly he had no direct learning of the faith. It was that he was a very intelligent man and had the sympathy and consideration to try and help the Muslim cause. For this reason he tried to provide answers to what he perceived as objections to Islam and to the Muslims but the way he adopted to respond was that he considered western thought, philosophy and way as the real standard and then tried to fit Islam to it. If he succeeded well and good but if he saw that he could not find a plausible explanation he dared negate its presence in Islam.

I try to view both these aspects of Sir Syed's life as distinct from each other. I have a lot of respect for him as a national leader but consider him an ordinary level writer / speaker and when I read such things by him I wish he had not written them. May God forgive these errors and exaggerations of his.

(Translated by Rakshanda Chaudry)


Articles by this author

Pundit Jawaharlal Nehru

Essence of Polytheism (9)

Mawlana Muhammad ‘Ali Jawhar

Essence of Polytheism (8)

Essence of Polytheism (7)

Essence of Polytheism (6)

Essence of Polytheism (5)

Essence of Polytheism (4)

Essence of Polytheism (3)

Essence of Polytheism (2)

Essence of Polytheism (1)

Responsibilities of Muslim Youth

Mu’atta’ Imam Malik (10)

Mu’atta’ Imam Malik (10)

Mu’atta’ Imam Malik (9)

Mu’atta’ Imam Malik (8)

Mu’atta’ Imam Malik (7)

Pundit Jawaharlal Nehru

Mu’atta’ Imam Malik (6)

Responsibilities of Muslim Youth

Mawlana Muhammad ‘Ali Jawhar

Mu’atta’ Imam Malik (6)

The Source of Jarh and Ta‘dil in the Qur’an

Mu’atta’ Imam Malik (5)

Mu’atta’ Imam Malik (4)

Sir Syed Ahmad Khan

Mu’atta’ Imam Malik (3)

Mu’atta’ Imam Malik (2)

Mu’atta’ Imam Malik

Surah Hujurat (3/3)

Surah Hujurat (2/3)

Surah Hujurat (1/3)

Surah al-Qiyamah (2)

Surah al-Qiyamah (1)

Surah Muddaththir part (2)

Surah Muddaththir part (1)

Surah al-Muzzammil

Gleanings from Tadabbur-i Qur’an

Some Difficulties in Surah Rahman

Collection of the Qur’an: Amin Ahsan Islahi’s View

Sūrah Muhammad (Part 3/3)

Sūrah Muhammad (Part 2/3)

Sūrah Muhammad (Part 1/3)

Sūrah Dukhān (Part 2/2)

Sūrah Dukhān (Part 1/2)

Companions (rta) of the Prophet (sws)

Sūrah Hujurat (Part 2/2)

Sūrah Hujurat (Part 1/2)

Sūrah Tūr (Part 2/2)

Sūrah Tūr (Part 1/2)

Sūrah Najm (Part 2/2)

Sūrah Najm (Part 1/2)

Sūrah Qamar (Part 1/2)

Sūrah Qamar (Part 2/2)

Surah Waqi‘ah (Part 1/2)

Surah Waqi‘ah (Part 2/2)

Sūrah Rahmān (Part 2/2)

Sūrah Rahmān (Part 1/2)

Sūrah Mujādalah (Part 1/2)

Sūrah Mujādalah (Part 2/2)

Sūrah Tahrīm (Part 1/2)

Sūrah Tahrīm (Part 2/2)

Sūrah Qalam (Part 1/2)

Sūrah Qalam (Part 2/2)

Sūrah Jumu‘ah

Sūrah Ma‘ārij (Part 1/2)

Sūrah Ma‘ārij (Part 2/2)

Sūrah Taghābun

Sūrah Munāfiqūn

Sūrah Hāqqah

Interrelation between the Qur’ān,  the Sunnah and the Ḥadīth

Sūrah Nuh

Difference between Hadith and Sunnah

Sūrah Jinn

Authoritativeness of the Akhbar-i Ahad

Sūrah Muzzammil

Sūrah Qiyāmah (Part 2/2)

Sūrah Qiyāmah (Part 1/2)

Causes of Hadith Fabrication

Surah Balad

Riwayah bi al-Ma‘na (Transmission by Meaning)

Surah Mursalat (Part 2/2)

Surah Mursalat (Part 1/2)

Primary Sources of Hadith Study

Sūrah Dahr (Part 2/2)

Sūrah Dahr (Part 1/2)

Companions (rta) of the Prophet (sws)

Sūrah ‘Abas (Part 2/2)

Sūrah ‘Abas (Part 1/2)

Excellence and Inherent Limitations of the Isnād

Surah Takwir

Surah Infitar

Basic Criteria to Sift the Sound from the Unsound Ahadith

Sūrah Mutaffifīn

Sūrah Fajr

Fundamental Principles of Understanding Ahadīth

Sūrah Tāriq

Sūrah Burūj

Sūrah A‘lā

Sūrah Shams

Surah Duha

Surah Tin

Sūrah Bayyinah

Sūrah ‘Alaq

Surah ‘Asr

Surah ‘Adiyat

Surah Kafirun

Surah Nasr

Sūrah Lahab

Sūrah Falaq

Qurayshite Descent: A Condition for the Khalīfah

Conditions and Limits of Obedience to the Rulers

Principles of Interpreting the Qur’ān (Part 2/2)

Principles of Interpreting the Qur’ān (Part 1/2)

The Institution of Consultation during the Reign of Rightly Guided Caliphs

Heads for Zakah Spending

Surah Baqarah (1-39)

Surah Tariq

Purification of Deeds

Usage of some Qur’anic Terms (1)

Surah Qadr


Surah Kawthar

Understanding the Qur’an: Some Initial Conditions

Surah Fil

Surah Quraysh

Surah Alam Nashrah

Surah Humazah

Surah Ma‘un

Surah Nas

The Philosophy of Prayer Timings

Surah Ikhlas

Surah Zilzal

Good and Evil (Part 1/2)

Good and Evil (Part 2/2)

Difference Between Hadith and Sunnah

Errors in the Current Mode of Preaching

An Analysis of the Meanings of the Surahs of Group six (Part 2/2)

An Analysis of the Meanings of the Surahs of Group six (Part 1/2)

Surah Takathur

Surah Qariah

The Concept of Equality Between Man and Woman

Man’s Place in the Universe

Man’s Place in the Universe

A Summary and Analysis of The Meanings of Surah Takveer

A Summary and Analysis of The Meanings of Surah Muddaththir

A Summary and Analysis of The Meanings of Surah Muzzammil

A Summary and Analysis of The Meanings of Surah Ma‘arij

A Summary And Analysis Of The Meanings Of Surah Mulk