Your Questions Answered

Your Questions Answered


Regarding the Status of the Hadith and Sunnah

Question: I used to read the Qur'anic text without knowing what it meant. Only recently, I began reading the translated Qur'an, and tried to solve the issues that were pestering my mind. I took care not to be misled; and cross-checked translations to be sure. It was a mind shattering experience. Blown to bits were the idols created in my mind by my parents, teachers, friends and mullahs. I realized the insignificance of rituals, the importance of deeds, the pitfalls of senseless and dangerous hero-worshipping (our Prophet's (sws)) that the Muslims of today have gone into, the horrors of the shameful treatment that we mete out to our women in the name of Islam and much, much more. But when I discussed my ideas with a few that I thought were capable of seeing the truth, lo and behold, I walked into open hostility, a dogged disbelief and a plain refusal to even listen to what I had to say. I became confused. I started thinking. Was I the only genius among so many to have understood the message? Are all these people and their stalwarts wrong? Am I looking for shortcuts in my religion to justify my own life-style? Am I being blasphemous? People started advising me to seek the help of 'ulama. I don't want to. I would have done that, had I been confused about something in the book. When my Allah says that He tells his message openly, clearly and without any ambiguity, why then should I seek these so-called 'ulama? I understand Him perfectly, clearly and precisely. I now believe, and very firmly, in the following: Mohammad (sws) was just a messenger and his duty was only to deliver the message (the Qur'an ). There is no place for any H~adith and Sunnah of the Prophet in our religion. It is this practice that has so thoroughly divided, disgraced and demonized our religion (post-Sep 11 events). The only H~adith and Sunnah that is to be obeyed and followed is that of Allah as given in his Book (the only error free document on earth). And nothing is to be sought from any man-recorded document (full of errors). There are, consequently, no sects in Islam and even a, so-called, star-worshipper could be a Muslim if he is following the message in the book. Please let me know your comments on this?

Answer: I believe that scholars have an important role to play in informing us about what religion tells us. I agree that their role is sometimes vastly exaggerated by many Muslims. However, like in all other fields, here too, you need to get help from more knowledgeable people to find out what the text says. When you read a translation of the Qur'an, for instance, you are, after all, following a scholar's views. However, we should be clear that scholars are human too, and therefore, they can go wrong as well. Moreover, we are responsible to the Almighty for our din in our own individual capacities. We will not be able to shift the blame of our faulty understanding and wrong doings on the scholars. Also, we know that scholars disagree with each other considerably. I, therefore, believe that we should listen to what the scholars have to say on various issues of religion but decidedly, form our own honest opinions. However, if we form these opinions without consulting the scholars in one way or the other, we would be committing a bigger fault, because we would then be venturing into a field for which we are not fully equipped to handle independently. I mean, if you claim that a certain verse means one thing and a scholar tells you that the principles of classical Arabic don't allow that meaning to be acceptable, how would you respond to it?

I agree with some part of what you have quoted above; but with the other part I disagree. For instance, I agree that H~adith compilation was a human exercise. I agree that there could be many errors in it. However, I can't understand how you can conclude about the Prophet (sws) that his job was only to deliver the Qur'an. Consider the following.

In Surah Jumu'ah (62), the Qur'an asks believers to gather for jumu'ah prayers when the call is given to them and to leave aside all worldly businesses (62: 9) The Qur'an has nothing to say about this issue any more. If you carefully look into the matter you would conclude that the Qur'an is accepting a jumu'ah prayer that was already taking place in Madinah under the supervision of the Prophet (sws). The only role the Qur'an has played in this matter is to ask the believers to be serious about it. In other words, the Qur'an is acknowledging the role of the Prophet (sws) as a religious guide even in matters not mentioned in it. There are other similar examples as well in the Qur'an.

The fact of the matter is that the Prophet (sws) gave us two things: the Qur'an and Sunnah. The meanings of Sunnah have been most certainly confused. Many people wrongly believe that whatever the Prophet (sws) did constitutes Sunnah. The truth is that there are only a few religious practices which the prophet gave to the ummah as Sunnah to be followed. For example, circumcising boys, burying the dead in a formal way, saying 'id prayers etc. In fact, none of these religious practices was originated by Muhammad (sws) himself but were the Sunnah of all the prophets before him as well.

H~adith are the collections compiled by scholars which contain the record of the Prophet (sws). Most certainly it was the result of a human effort, though its status has been exaggerated by many Muslims. However, the kind of efforts that Muslim scholars have put in to preserve the H~adith record has no parallel in human history. If you accept history written by a single historian seriously, you can't ignore the record collected by the doctors of H~adith with the help and involvement of hundreds and thousands of narrators, each one of who was thoroughly investigated for his/her character, and memory etc. I am sure that there can still be unacceptable stuff in the H~adith literature, but to ignore it is to ignore an extremely valuable treasure of knowledge about the most important man in the world for us.

If you don't accept a H~adith because you honestly think that it is against the Qur'an or common sense, you have a right to do so. But to reject the H~adith literature in its entirety is, to me, an exaggerated reaction to a problem that could be solved by being a little careful.

I don't agree with you that the differences amongst Muslims are because of Sunnah. In fact, Muslims are completely unanimous on a major part of the Sunnah: the hajj, five prayers, Ramadan etc., for instance. Differences could also emerge in the interpretation of the Qur'an as well. For instance, I strongly disagree with you in your understanding that a star worshipper could also be a follower of the Qur'an. The one thing that the Qur'an has clarified to its readers beyond any doubt is that shirk (polytheism) is not acceptable in any form under any circumstances.

I have a feeling that there are some questions in your mind about Islamic teachings that have emerged because of the conventional religious understanding. Your inability to find convincing answers to them from the traditional sources may have led you to the views that you have expressed. If you could talk about them, maybe, you may find my views closer to yours, even with our difference of opinion on the issue of Sunnah and H~adith. There is no doubt in my mind that the Qur'an is the primary source of knowledge in Islam.

Can We call the Qur'an a Poetic Masterpiece?

Question: I always thought the Qur'an was a poetic masterpiece, whereas the Qur'an itself seems to say that it is no poetry. What I gathered from it is that we should not associate poetic qualities to the Qur'an, and that it is above that, and this was an answer to the non-Muslims who used to call Prophet (sws) a poet. However, should I still consider the Qur'anic literary style a poetic style, and would it be okay to call it "poetry"?

Answer: My understanding is that the Qur'an incorporates in its text a style that is similar to poetry, but unlike poetry, it is not based on exaggerated statements that have to do with imaginations of the poet. A poet is tempted to go for untrue and exaggerated claims because he has to bring rhyming words in his verses and also to stir emotions of the readers. Qur'anic verses rhyme as well, but they are free of the limitation of poetry, because God has no limitation for expressing ideas; and He is in no need to unnecessarily stir emotions of people. It is because of the rhyming nature of the Qur'anic text that it is amenable to memorizing much more easily than prose.

It is, therefore, not correct to call the Qur'an a masterpiece of poetry. It is God's word, which has adopted a style that is close to poetry in appearance, although it doesn't have the weaknesses of poetry. According to some experts, the Qur'anic text is closer to the style of orators who address a large audience, and in the process, they address different segments of it, interchanging the focus of address very now and then.

Atonement of broken Oaths

Question: A close friend swore on the Qur'an about not doing something (which was obviously bad). But after a few days, he broke his oath as he says he couldn't help it. The person who made him swear doesn't know about it, but my friend feels bad about it. I have heard that there is an atonement (kaffarah) for breaking an oath on the Qur'an . Please can you let me know very precisely about what needs to be done. What is the atonemen?

Answer: In response to your query, The verse of the Qur'an says:

Allah will not call you to account for what is inadvertent in your oaths. But He will hold you accountable for that which you solemnly swear. The penalty for a broken oath is to feed ten indigent persons with such food as you normally provide to your own family, or to clothe ten needy people, or to free one slave. The one who cannot afford any of these must fast three days. This is the expiation for breaking your oaths. Therefore, be mindful of your oaths. (5:89)

Explanation of the Hadith on Illicit Relations

Question: Can you please explain this Hadith? Also the Answer from the Prophet (sws) is not included. Can you tell me what was the answer of this question?

Narrated Sahl Ibn Sa'd: A man said, "O Allah's Apostle! If a man finds another man with his wife, should the husband kill him?" Later on I saw them [the man and his wife] doing li'an in the mosque. (Bukhari, No: 4855)

Answer: The answer of the Prophet (sws) is not mentioned because the later part of the Hadith gives a good indication what his answer might have been. If a husband suspects his wife of having illicit relations with someone else, the process of li'an has been recommended. The following is what the Qur'an says about it:

Those men who accuse their own wives [of adultery] but have no witness except themselves, each one of them shall be made to swear four times by Allah that his charge is true, and the fifth time calling down upon himself the curse of Allah if he is lying. As for the wife, the punishment shall be averted from her if she swears four times by Allah that his [her husband's] charge is false and the fifth time calls down the wrath of Allah on herself if his charge is true. (24: 6-9)

There is no way a husband can kill his wife or the man he sees her with for that reason. There are only two reasons for which a person can be killed, and in both cases no individual can do it on his own. It has to be done by the state. The reasons are stated in the following verse:

Whoever kills a person, except as a punishment for murder or mischief in the land, it will be [written in his book of deeds] as if he had killed all the human beings on the surface of the earth. (5:32)

Articles by this author

Your Questions Answered

Abdus Sattar Ghauri (A Warrior of a Rare Breed)

Experiences, Questions, Analysis

Ishaq Nagi: A Dear Brother in Faith

Why Islamic Ethics?

The Christian God versus the Muslim God

Should We take Interest in Cricket and Sports ?

Experiences, Questions, Analysis

Why Islamic Ethics?

The Keep-it-Simple Rule and Islam

Experiences, Questions, Analysis

Your Questions Answered

Some Popular Misconceptions of the Muslims

The Originalist Approach to Understanding Islam

How is Faith acquired and strengthened?

Your Questions Answered

Your Questions Answered

Your Questions Answered

Your Question Answered

What is Riba?  (A Critical Evaluation of its Understanding (1))

Your Questions Answered

Your Questions Answered

Regarding Atonement of Broken Oaths

Your Questions Answered

Your Questions Answered

Your Questions Answered

Your Questions Answered

Your Questions Answered

Your Questions Answered

Humans Rights Law and Islamic Shari‘ah: Areas of Compatibility and Conflict

Why is Riba Al-Fadl Unacceptable?1

Questions on ‘Experiencing Jinn’

Experiencing Jinn

Religious Tolerance: An Islamic Perspective

A Quarter of a Century Ago

Why is He Annoyed?

Muslim-Christian Relations

Spreading Evil the Indirect Way

Condemnation of Concentration of Wealth


Never Forget your Poor Relatives

Betraying the Spirit of Law

Your Questions Answered

Juristic Differences

Prevent Evil from Spreading

The Two Levels

Spending in Allah’s Way

Ever Fallen Ill?

The Citizens of Paradise

Are Marxism and Islam Mutually Compatible?

A Believer’s Day

Allahu Akbar

Women’s Rights: Two Extremes

Is God an Intellectual Reality?

Rescuing the Near Ones from Hell

The Call to Eternity

This Worldly Life: A Trial For Man

The Message of Death

Religious Tolerance: The Islamic Perspective

The Prophethood of Muhammad (sws)

Belief in God

Why Economics?

Can Bank Lending be Islamically Fair?

Why Islamic Ethics?

Qur’an: The Primary Source of Islam

Some Popular Misconceptions of the Muslims

The Qur’anic Law of Guidance

The Question of Photography

The Status of the Taravih Prayer

Islamic Economics: An Emphasis on Spending and Utilisation of Resources

Relationship of Divine Law with Human Intellect

A Critical Look at the Alternatives to the Popular Models of Interest Free (IF) Banking

Recitation For Departed Souls

Following Islam

The Question of Original Sources

The Status Of The Taraaveeh Prayers

Following Islam



The Quran And Wadhu






Religious Judgements

“Tadabbur-i-Qur’an” Compared (Surah Faatiha II)

Recitation for Departed Souls


The Question of Original Sources

“Tadabbur-i-Quran” Compared

Restrictions on Women



Is God An Intellectual Reality?

Regular Prayers