Mr. Ghamdi is hard at work, trying to promote Religious Darwinism. His total argument is "offer prayer, keep fast, pay zakah, do hujj and remember Allah. Do not try to establish or do not strive for an Islamic socio political economic system, but if it happens by itself then it is well and good." This is a term like Darwin Theory of evolution that says: "Let things happen as they are happening and Islamic state may come in existence through evolution. We really do not have to interfere with social evolutionary process." As if Mr. Iblees is sitting dormant or as if all the Socio political economic systems that have ruled the parts of the world in the past or in present came into existence on their own. It is to suppose that all the unbelievers who are milat-e wahida (singe community) will allow this natural evolution of Islamic Socio Economic Political system to happen on its own. To me this is flawed logic, basically telling the Muslims all we are required to do is to do our rituals and If Islamic state will come into existence by natural evolution then well and good, else just be it.
Thank you for sharing your views. However, would it not be better to critically evaluate the arguments proffered by Ghamidi sb -- arguments drawn from the Holy Qur'an -- on the issue under discussion and point out their flaws?
Muslims should be very academic as well as sincere in their approach to religion. If we think that there is something wrong in a viewpoint then instead of emotional outbursts we should critically evaluate the opinion and show how it is erroneously derived from the sources.